The Cost of Home

Owning a Home

How Much Does a Home Warranty Cost?

Marcos Salles By Marcos Salles Updated 12 min read

Quick answer

A home warranty costs about $56 to $59 a month, or roughly $672 to $704 a year, with most plans between $47 and $82 a month. You also pay a service fee of about $65 to $150 each time a technician visits. The plan pays off mainly when a big item fails, such as a water heater or a furnace, and rarely on small repairs. Coverage limits, exclusions and pre-existing conditions decide whether a claim gets paid.

A homeowner at a wooden kitchen table holding a multi-page contract with highlighted lines, a pen, a calculator and a mug, with a dishwasher and refrigerator in the background
Realistic AI-generated image, not a photo.
On this page

A home warranty is not a warranty in the usual sense. The Federal Trade Commission says these plans are really service contracts: you pay for them, and for a set period they cover repairs or replacement of things like appliances or an air conditioning system. This guide puts the price of that contract next to what the repairs cost without it, using sources I read on November 16, 2026.

I did not find an official government survey of what home warranties cost. The prices come from two consumer finance sites that quote plans and earn money when readers request quotes, and from the plan pages of the companies themselves. I show where they differ, which follows the rule in how I research costs: name the source and show how wide the range is.

What this guide coversThe price of a plan for a single-family home, the service fee on top, what plans cover and leave out, and the arithmetic of when one pays for itself. Prices are in U.S. dollars and are national figures: your quote depends on your ZIP code, your plan and the age of what is covered.

How much does a home warranty cost a month?

This Old House puts the average at $56 a month, or $672 a year, with plans between $47 and $82 a month ($564 to $984 a year). Forbes Advisor, which collected quotes for more than 50 plans from 17 companies for a single-family home in Austin, Texas, finds an average of $58.64 a month, with the cheapest plan at $27.99 and the most expensive at $105.58. Forbes says plans run from under $400 to more than $1,200 a year before service fees and add-ons.

The two sources measure differently, so their numbers will not match exactly. This Old House says it gathered more than 4,000 quotes from 13 companies in all 50 states, including homes under and over 5,000 square feet in urban and rural areas. Forbes used one home in one city. Both land close to $56 to $59 a month, so I use about $56 a month as the typical price for the rest of this guide.

CompanyMonthlyYearlyFee per visit
American Home Shield$36 to $100$426 to $1,205$100 to $125
Choice Home Warranty$60 to $68$695 to $792$100
Liberty Home Guard$57 to $68$684 to $816$65 to $125
First American$77 to $130$930 to $1,560$100 to $125
AFC Home Warranty$44 to $82$528 to $984$75 to $125

What five home warranty companies charge, from This Old House's collection of more than 4,000 quotes from 13 companies in all 50 states (2025 quotes, article updated October 20, 2026). Monthly and yearly ranges cover the plans each company sells; the service fee is what you pay each time a technician visits.

American Home Shield has both the lowest starting price in this table ($36) and one of the widest ranges, from $426 to $1,205 a year. Forbes quotes the same company at $29.99 to $89.99 a month, a different range for a different home and date. That is the main reason to get several quotes for your own address: the sticker price of one company can move a lot with the plan you pick.

What do service fees and add-ons cost on top?

The monthly premium is only part of it. Every company in both studies charges a service fee each time a technician comes. This Old House says the fee is typically $75 to $125, and Forbes finds $65 to $150 among the companies it reviewed. Some companies let you pick a higher fee for a lower premium, and the reverse. Forbes notes that because you pay the fee only when you make a claim, it is easy to leave out of a budget.

Add-ons cost extra. This Old House puts pools, septic systems and similar items at $3 to $30 a month, and Forbes says add-ons such as pools and spas, roof leaks and a second refrigerator generally run $5 to $30 or more a month. In a survey of 2,000 home warranty users, This Old House found that most paid service fees of $75 to $125 a visit, and that dissatisfaction rose sharply above $150.

What does a home warranty cover?

This Old House says plans cover repair or replacement of major systems and appliances that break down from normal wear and tear. Plans usually last one year. Typical items:

  • Systems: heating, air conditioning, ductwork, plumbing, plumbing stoppages, electrical and water heaters.
  • Appliances: built-in microwaves, dishwashers, garbage disposals, kitchen refrigerators, ovens and cooktops, clothes washers and dryers, and ceiling fans.

Most companies sell a systems plan, an appliance plan and a combination of both, and the combination costs more. A home warranty is not homeowners insurance. Insurance pays for sudden damage such as fire, theft or vandalism, while a warranty pays for items that wear out. You can have both, and my guide to homeowners insurance cost by state covers the other contract.

How much will a plan pay for one repair?

Less than the price of the item, in some cases. Plans have limits. American Home Shield, the most widely used company in This Old House's survey (41% of respondents), lists a cap for each type of item:

PlanItemsHVACApplianceWater heater
ShieldSilver20$5,000Not listed$1,000
ShieldGold27$5,000$2,000$1,000
ShieldPlatinum29$5,000$4,000$2,000

What the three American Home Shield plans pay at most, as listed on its plans page (read November 16, 2026). Every plan has a $50,000 total limit per agreement term. The page does not list a limit per appliance for the Silver plan, and it does not show prices, which depend on your ZIP code.

The ShieldPlatinum plan also lists up to $1,000 for roof leak repairs, which is not available for condos, townhomes or mobile homes or in Connecticut and Hawaii, and up to $2,000 per line for water, sewer and gas lines outside the home. The company says plans are subject to change and tells readers to check the plan agreement for service fees, limits and exclusions.

The caps matter against real prices. A $1,000 water heater cap covers my estimate of about $950 for a gas tank installed, but not a heat pump model, which costs several times as much in my water heater guide. A $5,000 HVAC cap covers my estimate of about $4,250 for a gas furnace, as in my furnace replacement guide, but a larger or more efficient system could pass it. The cap is the first number I would look at in any plan.

A technician in a navy shirt kneeling in a utility closet and shining a flashlight at the base of a gray water heater tank, with water pooled on the floor
A leaking water heater is the kind of claim where a plan's cap matters. Realistic AI-generated image, not a photo.

What does a home warranty leave out?

This Old House lists the common exclusions: cosmetic damage, damage from accidents, misuse or neglect, rust, corrosion or sediment buildup, improper installation or modifications, knobs, dials and shelving, pre-existing conditions whether known or unknown, structural parts such as foundations and load-bearing walls, and windows, walls and doors. Roof leaks are often an optional add-on. If a problem falls under an exclusion, the company denies the claim and you pay the repair.

The same site says more than 90% of claims in its 2026 survey were approved, and that a significant share of denials came from pre-existing conditions or lack of maintenance. I read that as good news with a catch: the plan pays when the contract says it does. The FTC says to assume that anything not listed in a service contract is not covered, and to look at whether the company can deny coverage if you skipped routine maintenance. Its list of questions fits a home warranty well: the upfront cost, hidden costs such as deductibles or a fee at each visit, limits on how much is reimbursed, whether accidental damage counts, how hard the claims process is and what the company's reputation is.

A technician in a navy shirt and cap kneeling beside an outdoor air conditioner condenser with its side panel off, holding a gauge set with blue and red hoses
A technician checks an outdoor air conditioner with a gauge set. Heating and cooling are the costliest items most plans cover. Realistic AI-generated image, not a photo.

Is a home warranty worth the money?

It depends on what breaks and when. Start with the math that does not change: at $56 a month you pay about $672 a year, and every claim costs a service fee of about $100. If one covered item fails, the plan can save more than the premium. If nothing fails, you paid for peace of mind and got nothing back.

BreakdownWithout planYou savePremium covered
Small appliance repair$250$1502.7 months
Refrigerator repair$400$3005.4 months
Gas water heater$950$8501.3 years
Gas furnace (80%)$4,250$4,1506.2 years

My arithmetic. It assumes the item is covered, the claim is approved and the plan pays the full repair or replacement, leaving you the $100 service fee. The last column divides what you save by the average premium of $56 a month. Repair prices are from my guides on appliance repair, water heaters and furnaces; the water heater and furnace figures are my rounded estimates for a gas model installed.

On a $250 appliance repair, the plan saves about $150 after the fee, which covers under three months of premium. You would need about 4.5 such repairs in a year to break even, because $672 divided by $150 is 4.5. A gas water heater that fails is the other way around: one claim can pay for more than a year of premium. A furnace claim can pay for six. I found no national figure for how often a covered item fails in a year, so I cannot tell you the odds, and the table assumes the claim is paid in full.

Over ten years the premium alone comes to about $6,720. For comparison, replacing a gas water heater and a gas furnace once each, at my estimates of $950 and $4,250, comes to $5,200. So a plan can lose to the repairs if the home needs little, and win if the water heater, furnace and air conditioner are all near the end of their lives. In my opinion, a plan makes the most sense for an older house with old equipment and no cash set aside, and the least for a newer home with a cushion in the bank.

The FTC points to a different route in its guide to service contracts: after weighing the coverage, you may find that putting money aside in a savings account is a better option, and you pay for repairs from it. At $56 a month, that account would hold $672 after a year. My guide on home maintenance cost per year shows what owners actually spend, and my guide on repairing or replacing an appliance shows what a typical repair runs.

How can you pay less?

  • Get at least three quotes. This Old House recommends it, and the ranges in the table above show why: the same company can quote very different prices.
  • Pay annually. This Old House says some companies discount the annual payment, and in its survey nearly 54% of users preferred it.
  • Choose the service fee. Where the company allows it, a higher fee lowers the premium. That helps if you expect to claim rarely and mostly for large items.
  • Skip add-ons you do not need. A pool or septic add-on is $3 to $30 a month on top of the plan.
  • Read the contract before you pay. The FTC says to look at limits, exclusions and fees, and to search for the company's name with words like "review" or "complaint."

Promotions change often. On November 16, 2026, American Home Shield's plans page advertised 50% off select plans for a full year of coverage, so check the offer and the plan agreement before comparing prices.

What should you watch for?

The FTC warns about unwanted calls and mail about service contracts. It says these offers can arrive years after you bought something, that the callers are usually not related to the company you dealt with, and that marketers may use high-pressure lines such as "act now, your warranty is about to expire." Buying from a telemarketer can be risky because the company behind the contract may be gone when you need it. If you have a problem with a contract, the FTC says to report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to your state attorney general.

What can these prices not tell you?

  • They are not official statistics. This Old House and Forbes Advisor earn money when readers request quotes from the companies they list, and American Home Shield's page is its own marketing. I use them because no neutral national source exists, and I show both ranges.
  • The sources use different samples. This Old House quotes were collected in 2025 across the country, while Forbes used a single home in Austin, so a plan for your address can be above or below both.
  • The break-even table assumes a paid claim. A denied claim, a repair above a cap or a pre-existing problem would change the result.
  • Rules differ by state. I did not check each state's regulation of these contracts. The FTC says to check with your state consumer protection office.
  • Prices change. I read This Old House (updated October 20, 2026), Forbes Advisor (audited October 8, 2026) and the American Home Shield plans page (November 16, 2026).

For what the house costs to own beyond repairs, see my guide to the monthly cost of owning a home. For a repair that a plan with exterior line coverage may help with, see what a sewer line camera inspection costs. More guides on costly fixes are in the Home Repairs section.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a home warranty cost a month?

About $56 a month on average, or $672 a year, according to This Old House, with most plans between $47 and $82 a month. Forbes Advisor finds an average of $58.64 a month. Your price depends on your ZIP code, the plan and the size of your home.

What is a service fee on a home warranty?

It is what you pay each time a technician visits for a claim, on top of the monthly premium. This Old House says it is typically $75 to $125, and Forbes Advisor finds $65 to $150 among the companies it reviewed. Some companies let you choose a higher fee for a lower premium.

Is a home warranty the same as homeowners insurance?

No. Homeowners insurance pays for sudden damage such as fire, theft or vandalism. A home warranty is a service contract that covers repair or replacement of systems and appliances that break down from normal wear and tear, according to This Old House. The FTC also notes these plans are service contracts, not true warranties.

What does a home warranty not cover?

Common exclusions are cosmetic damage, damage from accidents, misuse or neglect, rust or sediment buildup, improper installation, pre-existing conditions and structural parts such as foundations and load-bearing walls. Roof leaks are often an optional add-on. Read the contract, because the FTC says anything not listed should be assumed not covered.

Is a home warranty worth it?

It can be when an old water heater, furnace or air conditioner fails, because one claim can save more than a year of premium. For small repairs it rarely pays: on a $250 appliance repair you would need about 4.5 repairs a year to break even, by my arithmetic. The FTC suggests comparing it with saving the same money yourself.

How much will a home warranty pay for a repair?

It depends on the plan limits. American Home Shield lists up to $5,000 per HVAC system on all three plans, up to $1,000 to $2,000 per water heater, and up to $2,000 or $4,000 per appliance on the Gold and Platinum plans. Each plan has a $50,000 total limit per agreement term.

Can you cancel a home warranty?

The sources I read do not give one rule for every company. The FTC says to ask about fees to cancel or transfer a contract before you buy and to read the details of the contract. Plans typically last one year, according to This Old House.

Sources

Marcos Salles

Marcos Salles

Founder and editor, The Cost of Home

I write and check every guide on this site myself, working from public data. The sources behind each number are listed at the end of the article, so you can check them too.

How I research costs

Keep reading

Three two-story detached houses on a residential street behind a brick neighborhood entrance sign with a flower bed, a sidewalk and a curb in the foreground

Owning a Home

Average HOA Fees: What They Cost and What They Cover

The typical owner who pays an association fee pays about $81 a month, but condos run far higher than houses. See fees by home type and region, what they cover, and what to ask about special assessments.